Revisionist History of the Marty Hurney Era

USA TODAY Sports

2002-2010 was a trying time for Panthers fandom. From Super Bowl contenders to league worst, the Marty Hurney era was a roller coaster ride of emotions. Let’s take a look at what might have been had JR signed Nostradamus as GM instead of the Marty-r…

It's that time of year again, Panthers fans! Skies are blue, the birds are chirping, and unicorns are riding magical rainbows of lollipops and... Look, its mini-camp time. You know, that time of year when we kid ourselves into thinking that Everette Brown is the steal of the draft; that Bruce Nelson is the next Dermontti Dawson; that Ryne Robinson is going to make Devin Hester look like Gilbert Brown; that Mike Wahle is the last piece needed for a successful Super Bowl run. Every player looks awesome without pads on, and this is that magical period before each season begins when the fans of all thirty-two teams believe their team is going to the Super Bowl (except the Browns of course, because come on...)

The point is, this is the time of year for optimism. Possibilities are endless. Rookies are suiting up for the first time, veterans are presumably a year older and wiser, and coaches have definitely learned lessons from the failures of yesteryear, right? It is also and most importantly that time of year when team sites and fan blogs turn into warzones. Eternal optimists face off against objective realists in duels to the death. Pessimists troll the comment threads like Tool fans on a Bieber blog, causing further mayhem. Eventually, someone will mention Arman... Nevermind.

Inevitably, around week two of the preseason a melee breaks out. You know the one. Some wiseguy remarks that so-and-so isn't looking so hot in his third season, and we should have picked (insert diamond-in-the-rough candidate here) instead. It is as if there wasn't a perfectly reasonable explanation for why the aforementioned DITR fell to the seventh round in the first place, or out of the draft altogether. These arguments are the worst. Every time I hear about Tom Brady being drafted in the sixth round I want to shoot myself in the face with a Super-Soaker full of acid. Ok, that's extreme. Substitute water from the Cape Fear River for acid and it'd be more accurate, but I digress...

I am going to attempt to put these arguments to rest once and for all. I have conclusively and exhaustively researched the draft-classes from the Hurney era and built the ultimate Carolina Panthers team that might have been. For some of you (the eternal pessimists), this may be the single most depressing moment of your lives. For others it will be enlightening in a soul-searching sort of way, as it was for me, but more about that later.

That being said, I guess it is time to talk a little about my methodology. For our purposes I assumed that injuries still happened (i.e. Smitty still lost the whole 2004 season, Dan Morgan still endured multiple concussions, etc.). I also did not play around with re-signing guys I feel we should have kept. If they left the team via free-agency or were cut in real life, that did not change in this simulation.

I also understand that many of the unexpected gems in these draft classes could have ended up as huge busts with us due to differences in coaching, scheme, or other circumstances. However, what we are doing is called revisionist history for a reason, and therefore we are assuming those players all reached their same potential with the Panthers.

As far as the draft goes, basically I started off with a clean slate just as Marty Hurney did. I took the same roster we had coming out of 2001, the same draft picks we had going into the 2002 draft, and I put together the best possible draft and UDFA class that I could based on the real-life performances of those players to date. I did not do any cockamamie draft-day trades, so other than the fourth rounder we got for Jay Williams in 2002, every other pick is exactly what we would have been given based on our projected record.

2002

I think we can all agree that Julius Peppers was the right pick at number two overall. Regardless whether you fall into the "love him" or "hate him" camp, Pep was undoubtedly a better selection than David Carr or Joey Harrington would have been. After the first round, however, Hurney's strategy fell apart. Will Witherspoon was a decent hit in the third round, but every other selection could have been better spent elsewhere. Of course, hindsight is 20/20...

2002 - Actual 2002 - Revised
1 Julius Peppers 1 Julius Peppers
2 Deshaun Foster 2 Clinton Portis
3 Will Witherspoon 3 Will Witherspoon
4 Dante Wesley 4 David Garrard
5 Randy Fasani 5 Jonathan Goodwin
5 Kyle Johnson 5 Aaron Kampman
6 Keith Heinrich 6 Justin Hartwig
7 Pete Campion 7 Bart Scott
7 Brad Franklin 7 Brian Russell

It would have been better to grab Clinton Portis than Deshaun Foster for obvious reasons, but David Garrard would have solidified our backup QB position for a long time, unlike Randy Fasani. Goodwin, Kampman, Hartwig, Scott, and Russell have all started and played well in the NFL, whereas the guys we chose were basically camp bodies that got to keep their jobs because we had no one better. Add in the UDFA class of James Harrison, Ma'ake Kemoatu, Bret Keisel, Kelly Herndon, and Ryan Clark, and the 2002 Panthers could have gotten very deep, very fast.

2003

Even with Hurney's weaker draft, the Panthers reached the Super Bowl in 2003 as the "Cardiac Cats". Hate on George Seifert all you want, but the man gave us the nucleus of Steve Smith, Mike Minter, Mike Rucker, Dan Morgan, and Kris Jenkins to build around. I would have made the same move Hurney did in signing Jake Delhomme as a free-agent; it was a low-risk, high-reward maneuver. I redrafted 2003 accordingly:

2003 - Actual 2003 - Revised
1 Jordan Gross 1 Jordan Gross
2 Bruce Nelson 2 Anquan Boldin
3 Mike Seidman 3 Asante Samuel
3 Ricky Manning 4 Ike Taylor
4 Colin Branch 4 David Diehl
5 Kindal Moorehead 5 Antonio Gates
7 Walter Young 6 Kris Dielman
7 Casey Moore 7 Brandon Moore

As you can see, I kept Gross as the first pick. Hurney was admittedly good at first round selections, but his methodology fell apart in the later rounds on a regular basis. Had we not gotten involved in stupid trade-backs in '02 and '03, we could have landed Anquan Boldin to pair with Moose, which would have allowed us to use Smitty in the slot, taking full advantage of his elusiveness and play-making ability. Asante Samuel and Ike Taylor would be eventual upgrades at the corner position; David Diehl is one of the most versatile and underrated linemen of the last two decades; Kris Dielman is a multiple time Pro-Bowler at LG; and Antonio Gates would have provided the most timely and capable replacement for Wesley Walls that we could hope for. Finally, had we snatched up UDFA Tony Romo and stashed him on the practice squad, the Panthers roster could look very different today.

2004

2004 - Actual 2004 - Revised
1 Chris Gamble 1 Karlos Dansby
2 Keary Colbert 2 Darnell Dockett
3 Travelle Wharton 3 Jared Allen
5 Drew Carter 4 Jason Peters
6 Sean Tufts 5 Andy Lee
7 Michael Gaines 6 Cullen Jenkins
7 Wes Welker

Having picked up Ike Taylor and Asante Samuel in the previous draft, the trade up to pick Chris Gamble becomes unnecessary. This saves us our fourth round pick in 2004. Instead, we pick Karlos Dansby who will learn for a year behind Dan Morgan and Bart Scott before taking over the Sam LB spot when we refuse to match Will Witherspoon's RFA offer in 2005. Instead of Colbert, we take Darnell Dockett to mold behind Brentson Buckner. Jared Allen is a steal in the third round; Jason Peters gets drafted as he should have; we snatch up Andy Lee to replace the troubled Sauerbrun; Cullen Jenkins joins his brother on the D-line and Wes Welker comes in to replace Smitty at punt returner and spell him in the slot. When we grab UDFAs Willie Parker, Vonta Leach, and Jordan Babineaux, the new-and-improved Panthers are shaping up as a force to be reckoned with.

2005

2005 - Actual 2005 - Revised
1 Thomas Davis 1 Aaron Rodgers
2 Eric Shelton 2 Vincent Jackson
3 Evan Mathis 3 David Stewart
3 Atiyyah Ellison 4 Darren Sproles
4 Stefan Lefors 5 Michael Boley
5 Adam Seward 5 Chris Harris
5 Geoff Hangartner 5 Bo Scaife
5 Ben Emanuel 6 Jay Ratliff
6 Jovan Haye 6 Reynaldo Hill
6 Joe Berger 7 Brandon Browner

With our vastly improved roster I assume we wouldn't have had as significant a drop-off in record as we did due to the infamous injury bug of '04. Therefore, I simulated a lower draft position. With our two outside LB positions locked down by James Harrison and Karlos Dansby and Thomas Davis being gone by the time our pick comes up, we take the freefalling Aaron Rodgers instead to groom behind Jake Delhomme. In the second round we lock down the future of the WR position with V-Jax, especially in light of Smitty coming off his devastating broken leg. David Stewart will solidify the RT position for years to come and Darren Sproles is a value pick at the "Swiss-Army Knife" position. Boley, Harris, Scaife, Ratliff, and Hill provide valuable depth and will push for starting roles in the future.

2006

2006 - Actual 2006 - Revised
1 DeAngelo Williams 1 Nick Mangold
2 Richard Marshall 2 Owen Daniels
3 James Anderson 3 Jahri Evans
3 Rashad Butler 4 Kyle Williams
4 Nate Salley 5 Omar Gaither
5 Jeff King 6 Courtland Finnegan
7 Will Montgomery 7 Marques Colston
7 Stanley McClover

Looking over the revised 2006 roster I came to the conclusion that at this point we truly would have been able to adopt a BPA draft strategy. We just have no glaring holes at this point. Once again, I have taken our increased depth into account and simulated a better record and lower draft position than we had in real-life. Therefore, instead of DeAngelo we take Nick Mangold to be the general of the O-line. Owen Daniels gives us quality depth behind Antonio Gates; Jahri Evans holds down the RG position for years; Kyle Williams is a beast at DT; Finnegan is an upgrade at CB and we all know what Colston can do.

2007

As much as it pains me to say it, in my simulation we do not pick high enough to select Jon Beason. That is because barring some kind of malevolent intervention by a higher power I just assume we would at least be in the Super Bowl every year going forward. Therefore, all of my picks from this point on could be had with the final selection in their respective rounds.

2007 - Actual 2007 - Revised
1 Jon Beason 1 Eric Weddle
2 Dwayne Jarrett 2 Charles Johnson
2 Ryan Kalil 3 Dashon Goldson
3 Charles Johnson 4 Desmond Bishop
4 Ryne Robinson 5 Brent Grimes
5 Dante Rosario 6 Tramon Williams
5 Tim Shaw 7 Matt Prater
7 C.J. Wilson

We take future All-Pro Eric Weddle at the end of the first. We no longer need Kalil due to having Mangold on the roster, so in the end we take Charles Johnson and Desmond Bishop and follow by beefing up the secondary. Dashon Goldson, Brent Grimes and Tramon Williams provide an immediate boost in quality depth and we take Matt Prater in the seventh to push John Kasay.

2008

2008 - Actual 2008 - Revised
1 Jonathan Stewart 1 Curtis Lofton
1 Jeff Otah 2 Jamaal Charles
3 Charles Godfrey 3 Carl Nicks
3 Dan Connor 4 Brandon Carr
5 Gary Barnidge 5 Matt Flynn
6 Nick Hayden 6 Peyton Hillis
7 Hilee Taylor 7 Mike Tolbert
7 Geoff Schwartz 7 David Hawthorne
7 Mackenzy Bernadeau 7 Jameel McClain

We missed out on Jon Beason in '07 but hit a home run with Lofton in '08. Jamaal Charles replaces an aging Willie Parker, Nicks is a multiple-time Pro-Bowler, and everyone else is just gravy.

2009

2009 - Actual 2009 - Revised
2 Everette Brown 1 James Laurinaitis
2 Sherrod Martin 2 Mike Wallace
3 Corvey Irvin 3 Henry Melton
4 Mike Goodson 4 Arian Foster
4 Tony Fiametta 5 Matt Slauson
5 Duke Robinson 6 Danell Ellerbe
7 Captain Munnerlyn 7 Michael Bennett

When you are able to draft these players and none of them even get to see the field, you've got problems everyone else wishes they had.

2010

2010 - Actual 2010 - Revised
2 Jimmy Clausen 1 Rob Gronkowski
3 Brandon Lafell 2 Navorro Bowman
3 Armanti Edwards 3 Geno Atkins
4 Eric Norwood 4 Kam Chancellor
6 Greg Hardy 5 Greg Hardy
6 David Gettis 6 Stevie Brown
6 Jordan Pugh 7 Victor Cruz
6 Tony Pike
7 R.J. Stanford
7 Robert McClain

It is all smooth-sailing now. Gronk replaces the aging Gates at TE immediately, the "We could have had Geno Atkins and Victor Cruz!" debate is put to rest, and we get to keep the Kraken. All is well.

2011

2011 - Actual 2011 - Revised
1 Cam Newton 1 Orlando Franklin
3 Terrell McClain 2 Justin Houston
3 Sione Fua 3 K.J. Wright
4 Brandon Hogan 4 Richard Sherman
5 Kealoha Pilares 5 Tyrod Taylor
6 Lawrence Wilson 6 Bruce Miller
6 Zachary Williams 7 M.D. Jennings
7 Lee Ziemba

Justin Houston comes in as our new pass-rushing specialist from the weakside ‘backer position, Bruce Miller replaces Leach at FB and Richard Sherman is a steal. As an aside, I am not getting lazy here. There just really isn't much to say about these picks because there is no longer any real thought-process needed for making them.

2012

2012 - Actual 2012 - Revised
1 Luke Kuechly 1 Mitchell Schwartz
2 Amini Silatolu 2 Russell Wilson
4 Frank Alexander 3 T.Y. Hilton
4 Joe Adams 4 Miles Burris
5 Josh Norman 5 Alfred Morris
6 Brad Nortman 6 Bryce Brown
7 D.J. Campbell 7 Alphonso Dennard

By Hurney's final draft the roster looks so drastically different that it isn't even comparable. It is too early to tell how good many of these players will turn out to be, but I threw the results in for posterity's sake.

Final Roster and Conclusions

2012
Offense Player Age Defense/ST Player Age
QB Aaron Rodgers 29 LE Charles Johnson 26
Tony Romo 32 Aaron Kampman 32
Russell Wilson 23 RE Jared Allen 29
RB Arian Foster 26 Greg Hardy 24
Jamaal Charles 25 DT Geno Atkins 24
Darren Sproles 29 Kyle Williams 29
FB Bruce Miller 25 Henry Melton 27
Alfred Morris 24 Jay Ratliff 31
WR Vincent Jackson 29 LOLB Navorro Bowman 24
Steve Smith 33 K.J. Wright 23
Marques Colston 29 MLB Curtis Lofton 26
Mike Wallace 26 James Lauranaitis 25
Victor Cruz 26 Michael Boley 30
T.Y. Hilton 23 ROLB Justin Houston 23
TE Rob Gronkowski 23 Miles Burris 24
Antonio Gates 32 CB Brandon Browner 28
Owen Daniels 29 Richard Sherman 24
LT Jason Peters 29 Asante Samuel 31
David Diehl 31 Courtland Finnegan 29
LG Kris Dielman 30 Tramon Williams 29
Carl Nicks 27 FS Eric Weddle 27
C Nick Mangold 28 M.D. Jennings 24
Dan Koppen 33 SS Dashon Goldson 28
RG Jahri Evans 29 Kam Chancellor 24
David Stewart 30 K Matt Prater 28
RT Orlando Franklin 25 P Andy Lee 29
Mitchell Schwartz 23 KR Darren Sproles 29
T.Y. Hilton 23
PR T.Y. Hilton 23

I must say, this was truly an exhaustive exercise. I have been researching it all week and my eyes will probably be crossed for days from looking at so many tables, charts, and articles. Late yesterday afternoon when I sat down to begin writing the actual article to go along with the research, I discovered something. I love my team. I don't mean in the abstract way that we all love our team no matter what, but more that I love our players.

I was looking over this roster that would surely take the Panthers to multiple Super Bowls and that is loaded with probable Hall of Famers and I realized that too many names weren't on the list. There is no Cam, no Luke, no D-Will, Stewart, Tolbert, Olsen, Kalil, Beason, or Davis. Star and KK wouldn't have ended up here in all likelihood either. I sat here looking at this roster that I would gleefully take for a Madden franchise any day of the week, and realized that I wouldn't trade our Carolina Panthers for it. I love our guys, and Super Bowls be damned. This revisionist history manifesto was fun to ponder but I for one will take the team we have now. Now if Gettleman turns out to be this decade's Nostradamus?

Well, I won't complain too much I suppose...

X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

Join Cat Scratch Reader

You must be a member of Cat Scratch Reader to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Cat Scratch Reader. You should read them.

Join Cat Scratch Reader

You must be a member of Cat Scratch Reader to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Cat Scratch Reader. You should read them.

Spinner

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9341_tracker