Are the 2011 Panthers better than the 2008 Division winners?

I have stated on several posts that my biggest reason for believing in this team is that we have more overall talent than the 2008 Panthers.  The 2008 Panthers went 12-4 and won the division.  What I'm gonna do is compare the 2011 projected roster (based on keeping all important FAs) to the 2008 team.

QB - Newton vs. Delhomme


The most important position on the field is the QB position.  In 2008, we had Jake Delhomme.  He had a QB rating of 84.7, and threw for 15 TDs and 12 INTs, and also ran for 2 TDs.  That was Jake's year after his Tommy John surgery.  Remember that he completely stunk it up against the Raiders and Lions, but we won due to the other guys.  Those two games were the two following the bye week.  For the rest of the season, he played pretty well.  He provided the leadership and work ethic, and confidence, for our offense.  I think Cam will be much better than that, as a rookie.  Cam has already won over many players.  I think it's not to improbable for him  to throw for 15 TDs.  I definitely expect more than 2 rushings TDs.  I think he'll be more accurate than Jake, has a stronger arm and quicker release.  He's gonna make some rookie mistakes, but in the end, his talent and work ethic will overcome that.

Advantage: 2011 QBs


RB- Williams/Stewart/Goodson/Fiametta vs. Williams/Stewart/Hoover.

The 2008 team saw Williams run for 1500 yards, and score 20 total TDs.  The rookie Stewart ran for 800 yards and 10 TDs.  They became the first RB duo ever with both guys getting 800 yds and 10 TDs.  The following year, they were the first to get 1100 yards a piece.  In 2011, the running game will be better because Fiametta should be a better blocker than he was last year, and Goodson is also very talented.  What we really need to keep an eye on is play calling and if Fiametta really is better at picking up the blitz.  He's still no Hoov, though.

Advantage: 2011 RBs


WR/TE - Smitty, Gettis, LaFell, Edwards, Shockey vs. Smitty, Muhammed, Jarrett, Rosario

In 2008, Smitty averaged over 100 yards a game.  Moose finished with over 900 yards as well.  This happened with Jake throwing.  I think we'll be better this year because we'll have three solid receivers instead of two.  The real difference in the receiving corps is going to be how these young guys block downfield, and on certain outside running plays.  Moose was a really good blocker.  I think Cam's ability to run and the other weapons on offense open the door for Smitty to have another dominant season.  King and Rosario combined for 39 catches in 2008.  I think Shockey and Rosario will be closer to 70.

Advantage: 2011 WRs/TEs

OL - Gross, Wharton, Kalil, IDK, Otah vs. Gross, Wharton, Kalil, Bridges, Otah

I call this one  draw.  I don't know who's going to start at RG.  Otah was a rookie in 2008, and should be better as a veteran, but we haven't seen him play in over a year.  The OL in 2008 was pretty good.  Jake was only sacked 20 times.  Part of that was our dominance runnign the ball, and also Jake's decision making.  It will be hard to match the quality of the 2008 OL, but since 4 of those guys are still here, it's doable.

Advantage: Draw


DL:  CJ, McLain, Fua, Brown vs. Peppers, Kemoeatu, Lewis, Brayton

I think it's going to be difficult to match the Panthers DL from 2008.  Peppers had 14.5 sacks that year.  CJ could equal that number.  I think Brown will win the other starting job, but it could be Brayton, Hardy, or someone else.  Lewis and Kemo played good football that year, too, except when Derrick Ward ran for 200 yards against us.  So my 2011 DL roster includes three guys who have never been starters.  Think about that for a minute.

Advantage: 2008 DL


LBs - Davis, Anderson, Beason, Connor vs. Davis, Beason, Diggs

Diggs was a solid tackler, but a guy many people considered a solid back-up player who shouldn't start.  Adding some 3-4 schemes, Anderson and Connor to the mix makes the 2011 LB squad a real strength.  All four guys have the talent and skill to be Pro Bowlers.  I expect big things from this squad.  The key is going to be how close they have to play to the line to make up for lack of experience on the DL.  If we get good leads, though, then our defense should spend less time on the field overall.

Advantage: 2011 LBs


DBs - Gamble, Godfrey, Martin, Munnerlyn vs. Harris, Gamble, Lucas, Godfrey

The 2008 team struggled down the stretch.  Martin and Godfrey showed last year that they are a solid pair of starting safeties.  Harris was good at making big plays, creating turnovers, and run support.  The key is going to be Munnerlyn.  Munnerlyn will be lined up on #2 receivers like Julio Jones.  I'm hoping we bring in a vet FA and Munnerlyn can be the nickel.  I think our 2011 secondary is going to be better, though, because of better play from Martin and Godfrey.  We have moved on from bend but don't break.  We will be attacking more, and reacting less. 

Advantage: 2011 DBs


There you have it.  I've decided not to get into special teams and coaching.  We still have Baker and Kasay.  Ryne Robinson was returning kicks in 2008.  I think there is a consensus about the coaching staff in Carolina as well.  If you look at our 2008 team compared to 2011, though, you see so many familiar faces, and the talent is in place.  We were never in a rebuilding stage, and I think we all better get used to winning every year, not every other year. 

The content of these posts are those of the user/fan making the post only

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Cat Scratch Reader

You must be a member of Cat Scratch Reader to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Cat Scratch Reader. You should read them.

Join Cat Scratch Reader

You must be a member of Cat Scratch Reader to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Cat Scratch Reader. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.