Redskins vs. Panthers: Blogger Q & A
After a three week hiatus we are back with blogger Q & A. Kevin with Hogs Haven was kind enough to answer some questions I sent his way. Be sure to check his site for my answers to his questions. Without further delay, here we go.
Question 1: You've got John Beck starting at QB over Rex Grossman. Do you agree with the switch? What do you expect from Beck against the Panthers to call it a good day (other than a win)?
Kevin: Yea, I agree with the switch (Grossman needs the National Guard to escort him around in public in these parts). Rex simply does not protect the ball well. From 2003, when Rex entered the NFL, through 2011, Grossman has the highest interception percentage of any quarterback in the game (and then there's his 26 career fumbles, 16 lost). Sexy Rexy simply cannot protect the ball for the life of him. Last week was the last straw. Our defense just picked off Vick on their side of the field. We could feel the momentum changing, and then Rex turned it right back over. When Beck finally came in to start the 4th, he scored a TD and without doubt added a spark to our offense. It'd be foolish to extinguish it now.
I'm hopeful the Panther defense can force Beck to make some errors and help the offense with field position.
Question 2: I see Ryan Kerrigan has started well with 2 sacks and an INT. What former Redskin or NFL player would you most compare Kerrigan's game too?
Kevin: Hmm. That's tough to do since the Redskins were never a 3-4 defense in their history until just last year. He plays like a defensive end but rushes from the LB position (standing up). Despite being 30 pounds heavier, Kerrigan reminds me a bit of Redskins LB great, Ken Harvey. Kerrigan doesn't have the speed Harvey had, but they both are experts in shedding blocks and forcing fumbles (Kerrigan led the nation in forced fumbles with 7 at Purdue).
Rookie RT Byron Bell will have his hands full with the fellow rook Kerrigan. This could be a key match-up for the Redskin defense.
Question 3: You've done a little shuffling on the offensive line this week. What is your biggest worry (if any) based on the expected starting line- up Sunday?
Kevin: Oh man, our OLine situation is reaching Lindsay Lohan trainwreck status. Our entire running game was based off running behind Trent Williams and Kory Lichtensteiger (Left Tackle and Left Guard). They were easily our two best lineman and now they're out. Will Montgomery, our starting Center all year, is moving to Guard and a former seventh round pick, Erik Cook, steps in at Center. He's 6'6" so he has trouble staying low and had two false starts I believe last week. If the Redskins can't get the running game going, it's going to be a long day.
If our defensive line is going to have a good day this is their chance. I expect big things from the Panther D this Sunday.
Question 4: You've had a bit of RB by committee approach this season. Who do you expect to start and how do you expect the carries to be split between Torain/Hightower and Helu?
Kevin: Last week Shanahan announced Hightower was starting and then post-game he said he told the media that to give the Redskins an advantage. (Oooh that Shanny's a crafty one!!!) I fully expect Hightower to start. He's our best pass protection RB and has had three weeks to heal that shoulder. Ryan Torain and Helu will certainly see some action. I'd guess Hightower sees 50% and Helu/Torain split the other 50%.
I'm more worried about Torain than I am the other two. I'm sure given the Panther run D is last in the league (or near last) that the ‘Skins will hand it off a lot. How well they stop the run on 1st and 2nd down will determine a lot.
Question 5: Can we expect DeAngelo Hall on man up on Steve Smith much this game? How do you expect the Redskins to scheme their coverage on him?
Kevin: The Redskins aren't a team to stick to one coverage. Haslett has been a big fan of mixing in the casino blitz as of late (all out blitz leaving corners 1-on-1). With Cam Newton's size and athleticism, I expect the Redskins to shy away from that. A big concern is free safety, OJ Atogwe, has missed practice all week with a knee injury. Whoever is at FS, I expect him to be over the top of Steve Smith all day. Smith's ability to break tackles alone is reason to never leave him 1-1.
Good point about Smitty breaking tackles. I still hope they go deep to him but I also expect a good number of passes to TEs Jeremy Shockey and Greg Olsen.
Got a score prediction?
Kevin: The fact the entire country is betting Panthers makes me like the Redskins more. The Redskins are a team that loves to control the clock, which makes them a team that never puts up big points, so I like the Skins to win a snoozer, 17-13.
Snoozer? I guess he hasn't watched any of our games.
55 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
"the fact the the entire country..."
Interesting, in-depth prediction there. If the Panthers can hold them to 17 points they will win but I am sure that more than me think that so how could that be true? smh
by TXPanther on Oct 22, 2011 5:45 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
Well, not the entire betting portion of the country...
The line started Panthers favored by 3, and it’s since dropped to 2 1/2. That shows $ on the Skins, not the Panthers.
Nevertheless, I feel this is due to uninformed attitudes, based on the current W/L records of the teams. It’s hard to make a team that’s 3-2 an underdog to one that’s 1-5.
But after we blow the Skins out, those attitudes will be adjusted.
I know James matched our rushing O vs their rushing D, etc. and it looked pretty closely matched.
But look at it this way:
QB – huge advantage to Newton over Beck (or Grossman, after they have to bring him in, after the game’s out of reach, and Beck’s been beaten all to hell.)
RBs – huge advantage to Panthers again, as Williams and Stewart far outclass anybody the Skins put out there.
WR#1 – advantage again to the Panthers, as Smith’s having an All-Pro season, which is far and away better than anything Santana Moss can hope to produce with Beck at the helm.
WR#2 and #3 – same logic as WR#1, Newton will make Naanee (14 recs/169 yds) and LaFell (14/193) more productive than Jabar Gaffney (19/293) and the rest of their crowd.
TEs – Fred Davis has 22 catches, for 343 yds. How’s that match up against Olsen (25/282) and Shockey (18/259)? Thought so.
OL – sure we’re disadvantaged by Jeff Otah’s going on IR, but their OL is far more beat up, with 2 starters down at LG and LT, and the rest switching places. This hurts their running game, makes Beck an easier target, and again plays into our hands, in every way.
DL – they have 17 sacks, and I’ll give them that, as the only advantage, based on play thus far this year. But I don’t think they’ve played a team with an OL as cohesive as ours, which has only allowed 10 in 6 games.
LBs – at this point in my comparisons, we’ve left the skill positions behind (and every one of them favors us). But here, they have the advantage, with Orakpo, Kerrigan, Fletcher, and McIntosh forming a solid unit – whereas our guys are, with the exception of James Anderson, plug-ins and non-starters.
Secondary – I don’t see an advantage to either side. Our best CB, Gamble, is, IMO, better than Hall, but some may argue otherwise. In any event, I don’t see the game changed by these units, as they’ll all be reacting, not dominating the action.
ST – ours have been atrocious, and any team out there looks better by comparison. However, Brandon Banks returns punts and KOs for them, and he’s not done anything special. He’s hardly in the Devin Hester game-changer mode, averaging only 9.3 yds per PR, and 24.3 on KRs. This shouldn’t be a factor, unless poor tackling or blocking by one team or the other make it so.
Home field – BIG advantage for us, as the Skins are a decent home team, but less than average on the road. This year, they’ve only scored 16 and 17 in their 2 road contests (only able to score 17 on the Rams?!?)
In summary, games are usually decided by big players making big plays, and we have such a skill player advantage, that I can’t see our frustration continuing.
by bigdavis on Oct 22, 2011 6:58 PM EDT up reply actions 5 recs
great post, bigdavis!
you should think about making this a fanpost, and hopefully it’ll get to the front page. if you were ambitious, you could make this comparison for all teams, while James does his O vs D column.
i dedicate this signature to... my dog
by scatterbrain on Oct 22, 2011 7:15 PM EDT up reply actions
Panthers win offense, Skins win defense. If Atogwe is actually out that’s huge for the Panthers because Wash backup Safeties are terrible in coverage. If OJ plays, you are way underselling Landry/OJ.
Both OLs are missing 2 starters and undergoing changes which makes me lean towards a sloppy offensive game for both sides and I’d give the slight edge to the better Defensive team. Basically, like 90% of NFL games, it will come down to Special Teams and TO’s. Banks is no Armanti, you are definitely selling him short as well, his numbers are down because the KR blocking has been pretty awful this year for the Skins. I don’t see either team scoring 21+ points.
I can definitely see Carolina scoring more than 21
also, I don’t know if Panthers can “WIN” Offense against Redskins’ offense. I don’t like Offense vs. Offense, Defense vs. Defense.
I’d take Carolina’s offense, and a push for defenses. I like our secondary better, and I like our front line. their LBs blow ours out of the water.
i dedicate this signature to... my dog
by scatterbrain on Oct 22, 2011 7:26 PM EDT up reply actions
Well those are the comparisons bigdavis made, so I’m just saying Panthers have a better O, Skins have a better D. And I’m a fan of both teams, no chance it’s a push on defense, the Skins are way better. It’s also hard to separate LB/DL since they run different defenses.
And sure, they could score 21+, I just wouldn’t bet on it. We held the Cowboys w/o a TD and to 18 total points. We held the Eagles to 20, Giants at 14. The Skins play a very ball control/slow it down offense that takes away opportunities to opposing offenses, I think you will gain more respect for them after tomorrow. The Skins D though is very aggressive and can make big plays from their pressure.
If Cam makes mistakes, Wash wins a squeaker, if Cam can limit them and make big plays then Carolina should win by a couple scores.
yeah, you make a lot of sense :P
and to clarify about O vs O, D vs D… i like players of each position vs each other, but not the other way. otherwise, you’ve made some great points that i can’t debate!
i dedicate this signature to... my dog
by scatterbrain on Oct 22, 2011 7:52 PM EDT up reply actions
Our OL is only missing one starter.
It would be an error for you to consider our RG, Geoff Hangartner, as a sub for Geoff Schwartz.
He is far superior, as his play has borne out, and we were well-advised to sign him after Schwartz went on IR.
Bryan Bell at RT is our only actual sub, and our OL has great cohesive blocking skills. Our offensive numbers bear that out.
And I consider Landry/Atogwe as on a par with Godfrey/Martin. Now should Hines be pressed into action as a S, then you have an advantage in their comparison. Your defensive success has to do with your front 7, not your secondary.
Can your defense contain our offense? That’s what we’ll see in 13 hours. I predict “No.”
All of it?
You can certainly have a different opinion regarding the Safeties, but hardly concerning our RGs.
Come back after the game, and let’s see how it turns out. Nice talking to you.
meh, that part is more semantics. Schwartz was the starter in preseason. Hanny is only here because the guy got injured. There is too much involved for me to say who is better, I don’t study OL film or anything but that doesn’t really matter anyways. And you basing OL skill on our offensive numbers is silly since our running game without Cam has been pretty poopy.
You were certainly right about 1 thing - or half right...
One of the teams didn’t score 21 points.
Cam was unstoppable
-3 TO margin didn’t help either. And yeah, Atogwe was out also. When Cam starts playing like that consistently, it won’t matter how bad the Panthers D is or isn’t. Charlotte could be the next Colts.
love ya big d but
i disagree on RB’s. skins RB’s have 522 yards in 5 games, and torain and helu are both averaging over 5 ypc. panthers RB’s have 515 yards in 6 games. our RB’s are no longer special because we have an offense that clearly deemphasizes the position. whether or not they are more talented is irrelevant because the gameplan doesnt utilize the running game.
this year, simply put, they aren’t playing any better than the redskins RB’s. at the end of the yr double trouble will prob have a meager 1500 between them, if that. the panthers are now a pass first team, for the first time since steve beurlein was our QB. add in putting Otah on IR, and we just aren’t that good of a running team. more exciting? yes. more effective? jury’s out.
(and before someone argues our ranking in rushing stats, remember my point here is RB’s; cam’s scramble stats don’t make us a better running team; they make us able to get more first downs when we are passing the ball and everyone is covered)
SIMPLE AND PLAIN
That's right. One thing we have to remember about the
betting lines is that it isn’t a prediction. The line is where it is to draw equal $$$ from bettors on both teams.
by childeroland19 on Oct 23, 2011 8:31 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
But the movement of the line indicates the action at 3 was predominantly on the 'Skins, and the books had to knock it down a 1/2 point to reduce that imbalance.
Therefore my statement that the “entire betting country” WASN’T betting the Panthers. If it had been, the line might have changed to 3 1/2 to discourage any more of it.
While it's hyperbole to say that the whole country is thinking a Panthers win today...
for the most part, people seem to agree on expecting a Panthers win
Nobody fucks with the Jesus! -Big Lebowski
"17-13"
Ha. He hasn’t seen our defense.
by Panthster on Oct 22, 2011 5:50 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
I would have played Grossman another game or two before benching...
"It is now official... Cam Newton is now the face of our franchise.
by Caro2daheart... on Oct 22, 2011 5:52 PM EDT reply actions
Too bad about Grossman. I really wanted to use this pic

by Scrantsj on Oct 22, 2011 6:02 PM EDT reply actions 3 recs
The Panthers O-Line Will Face A Stronger Test Than At Any Time This Season
The Redskins have a very good pass rush at every position on their front 5.
3.5 sacks – From 3-4 OLB Brian Orakpo
3 sacks – From 3-4 DE Adam Carriker
2.5 sacks – From their NT’s (Barry Cofield – 1 sack, and backup Chris Neild -1.5 sacks)
2.5 sacks – From 3-4 DE Stephen Bowen
2 sacks – From 3-4 OLB Ryan Kerrigan
1 sack – From ILB Rocky McIntosh
This will be a very big test for the Panthers O-Line, and may prevent them from giving help to UDFA rookie RT Byron Bell, unless it comes from a TE.
i usually focus on one person with the offense/defense
mostly it’s been Cam Newton since he’s so new, so sensational… but I think i’ll focus on Bell/RBs this game, and on the D side, i’ll watch our DEs (a usual pick to watch). if the camera would allow it, i’d watch Smith/Hall every down.
i dedicate this signature to... my dog
How many of you knew that...
Will Montgomery, the Redskins injured starting center mentioned in this article, was the Panthers former seventh round pick. I remember Hurney saying that they would have picked him sooner in the draft if they knew how good he actually was after seeing him in practice and games. For some reason he became expendable.
A snoozer?
Has this guy seen Cam play this year? I can’t remember a time when it was exciting to see the Panther offense take the field.
You get what you put in and people get what they deserve.
by Disciple of Carolina on Oct 22, 2011 7:07 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
There has been a lot of bickering about their fans this week
Talking about Lindsay Lohan is just crossing a line. No matter how many things she steals or what not she is still awesomely sexy and she wins.
by doug2626 on Oct 22, 2011 7:28 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
That looks like something that slithered out of a meth lab
for a bottle of Night Train and a pack of Kool 100’s.
by Swamp Panther on Oct 22, 2011 9:43 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
This poor girl is about to take a very hard fall.
And there will be a high price to pay for the substances she’ll require.
Oh cool! Another zombie flick is coming out.
I love that genre.
Newton for '11 ROY!
Walker for '11 ROY!
Biyombo for '11 DPOY!
Lindsay Lohan "awesomely sexy"?
eew
by Buck Wild on Oct 23, 2011 2:02 AM EDT via iPhone app up reply actions
Meth teeth are a deal breaker.
"If ya ain't first, you're last."
- Ricky Bobby's Dad
"There is no evidence that the tongue is connected to the brain."
-Frank Tyger
by KaiserBromley on Oct 23, 2011 12:44 PM EDT up reply actions
Off Topic
Why have we worn white jerseys all season?
by doncarolina on Oct 22, 2011 9:23 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
@It's a tribute to Lindsay Lohan and her favorite white powder.@
by Swamp Panther on Oct 22, 2011 10:13 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Just in case you didn't know
it only works in the body of a comment.
I don't always fail, but when I do...
I do it awesomely.
by BusyBeingAwesome on Oct 22, 2011 10:48 PM EDT up reply actions
Yep, just figured that out.
Thanks BBA.
by Swamp Panther on Oct 22, 2011 10:50 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Didn't want to sound like a smartass
just wanted you to be able to have fun with it if you didn’t know.
I don't always fail, but when I do...
I do it awesomely.
by BusyBeingAwesome on Oct 22, 2011 10:59 PM EDT up reply actions
Smartass
"If ya ain't first, you're last."
- Ricky Bobby's Dad
"There is no evidence that the tongue is connected to the brain."
-Frank Tyger
by KaiserBromley on Oct 23, 2011 12:45 PM EDT up reply actions
Traditionally they've worn white in the first half of the season to combat the Charlott heat.
I don't always fail, but when I do...
I do it awesomely.
by BusyBeingAwesome on Oct 22, 2011 10:46 PM EDT up reply actions
For local fans
Its 10:53 am and they just said on 1110 WBT AM they will interview Greg Hardy shortly. I’ve never heard an interview with the Kraken so I thought it may be interesting.
by Swamp Panther on Oct 23, 2011 10:55 AM EDT via mobile reply actions
GAME DAY! GAME DAY!
DUDES, IT’S *&$%ING GAME DAY! GIMME AN OPEN THREAD! PANTHERSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
i dedicate this signature to... my dog
Kraken interview was short
Said he feels the young defense is getting better, said his almost sack of Matt Ryan was close but not close enough, they asked about having a fellow SECOND alum at QB said its cool but they’re all Panthers now. It was a softball interview.
by Swamp Panther on Oct 23, 2011 11:21 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
they need to open it when the party gets here, i.e. when scatterbrain gets here
i dedicate this signature to... my dog
by scatterbrain on Oct 23, 2011 11:33 AM EDT up reply actions
why am i not in charge of this place? GEEZ!!
i dedicate this signature to... my dog
by scatterbrain on Oct 23, 2011 11:33 AM EDT up reply actions
^ you answered your own question
@ dur @
As the great philosopher Yoda said "Try not! Do you must!"
by gdhood on Oct 23, 2011 11:50 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
:P
i dedicate this signature to... my dog
by scatterbrain on Oct 23, 2011 12:45 PM EDT up reply actions

by 
























