Panthers Vs Giants: Key Matchups
Although the Panthers gave the Giants an "old fashioned butt-whooping" last year, you can expect this game to be much closer. The Giants running attack should be more potent than it was last year, the defensive stars injured in last year's game are back, and the Giants new D-Coordinator has had a year to prepare for this game. Make no mistake Panther fans, this game will be a close one, the Giants are a very talented team and have a lot of anger from this matchup last year. If the Panthers are to win this one, they must exploit and win 5 key match-ups.
1. Geoff Schwartz and Mackenzy Bernadeau vs. Giants D-Line:
Although the Cats ran all over the Giants last year, they'll be replacing two starters on the offensive line for this game: Schwartz at RT and Bernadeau at RG. Both actually saw time last year and did quite well, but must prove now that they are quality O-line starting material. They must prove that they can handle the Giant D-Line, which is both deep and talented. Last year was really an anomaly for their D-Line, under performing and collecting only 32 sacks. This year though, they have retooled with a new D-Coordinator and added new players in Jason Pierre-Paul and Linval Joseph. With Justin Tuck, Chris Canty, Osi Umenyiora, Mathias Kiwanuka and these new guys, this line is going to be a challenge for our offensive line and if our running and passing game are going to be effective, it all starts up front with these guys...
2. TE's Jeff King, Dante Rosario, and Gary Barnidge Vs. Giants LB Corps:
If there is one weakness on this Giant defense, it has to be the Giant LB corps. Other than Michael Boley and seasoned vet Keith Bullock (who might not even play), there is really no one special here. Clint Sintim and Jonathan Goff are by no means household names. Respectfully, neither are our tight ends. However, if the Panthers are to be succesful on offense, the TEs must bully these linebackers around. In the run game, King must dominate the LB since the O-line will likely have its hands full. And in the passing game, Rosario and Barnidge must make themselves targets for Matt Moore, because outside of Smitty, there may not be much else for Moore to throw to. Therefore, the Panthers must exploit this match-up and have dominant play from the TEs....more after the jump...
3. CB Captain Munnerlyn Vs. Giants WRs:
With Steve Smith (the other, less talented one from USC of course...), Mario Manningham, Hakeem Nicks, Dominik Hixon, and Victor Cruz, the Giants have a very talented corps of receivers to throw to. This is evident as Eli threw for 4,000 yards last year (albeit not many yards against the Panthers last year...). Chris Gamble and Richard Marshall are more than capable of defending against the Giants top two receivers (whoever that may be), however Munnerlyn will see the field often as the Giants will likely utilize multiple WR sets, thus necessitating nickle and dime packages. Munnerlyn will face a very good challenge against these receivers, and if the Panthers are to stifle the Giants air attack, then a lot of the weight will have to be carried by Munnerlyn.
4. Panther D-Line vs Giant O-Line:
Yeah, yeah, yeah, we all know the story. Pep left, and critics cried that this D would be in shambles without him, yada, yada, yada...And we all know how the preseason went, as the D-line had 18 sacks in 4 games. Yes, the Panther D-line looked great in the preseason, but before putting the Panther's D-line on a pedestal, we've got to see how they perform in the regular season. This young and promising group, consisting of Brown, Brayton, Johnson, and Hardy will have to step up to stop this rushing attack and get after Eli to once and for-all start proving these critics wrong. Additionally, all of the nobody's in the middle of the line (Leonard, Hayden, Neblett, Landri, and Johnson) must prove that they are somebody and can hold the middle.
5. QB Matt Moore vs. Giant Defense:
Although Matt Moore played great at the conclusion of last season, he didn't look so hot in the preseason, and now he must prove this year he is worthy of the starting job. With a successful running attack, Moore might not have to be spectacular. However, if the running game has a mediocre performance, then the onus will really be on him to win this game through the air. Add in that the only proven target is Steve Smith on the field, and he might have to transform into Payton Manning for the Panthers to win. Either way, Moore has to be solid against this reformed Giant Defense...
The content of these posts are those of the user/fan making the post only
18 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Hate to be a Hater...
But, most rationally, I think Giants win.
Why?
Balance.
Yes, we have an AMAZING run game and star in Smitty, BUT the Giants have very good running game with a Smitty AND other accomplished receivers.
Additionally, there are just too many unknowns for the Panthers: How good is Moore really? Can we get someone else than Smitty to catch the pigskin? Will our D-line be as good as it was preseason? How will our LB corps fare with Beason, Connor, and Anderson?
The Panthers are definitely the underdog here, and it is just darn hard to get a win on the road…especially against a really hyped up, angry team…
Prediction:
NYG 24, CAR 16
I think it will be a tie.
As for their receivers, their site says Hixon is on injured reserve. However, that rookie Cruz looks like he’s something, so it doesn’t matter.
stuff 'bout stuff.
Panthers by a score, either TD (4 or 7) or FG (3)
Just don’t think the Giants have enough to overcome our defense and I question the Giant’s offensive line’s ability to get some lanes open and protect Eli.
If you think about how we stack up against them, we have a better offensive line, maybe an equally good defensive line, better linebackers and a better secondary. On the offensive side of the ball, clearly the real Smitty gets the nod, but all the other WRs for the Giants are better. Eli is probably better than Moore and because of that it’s probably safe to say they do have a stronger passing game. However, our backfield is honestly second to none and both Stewart and Williams can exploit a weak linebacking corp if they can get past the defensive line.
Historically, we tend to own the Giants. I think they’ve beaten us only twice since Fox took over: once in a deadly close matchup in ‘08 (Kasay missed a FG at the end which led to a loss) and a time before that in ’06 when Jake was out with a broken finger. Conversely, two times we’ve met up with the Giants, we have absolutely dominated them (23 – 0 in the playoffs and 41 – 9 last year).
All that combined and I think we have a slight edge over the Giants, but I do think it’ll be close. Close enough that if we have some disasters on ST we might be in trouble. It’ll be a good game, that’s for sure, but I am assuming that our offense is not as anemic as it has looked all pre-season. It’ll also be interesting to see how the G-men’s new defensive scheme works out for them.
Not quite as worried about STs as I would be normally
Apparently the Giant’s special teams are bad. Hopefully they will cancel each other out.
I think it's either going to be a very close, ugly game.
That we can hopefully pull out in the end. Either that or it’s going to be a repeat of the game last year, with us on the other end. We just have so much uncertainty still. Will our OL play like our accolades indicate, or will they play like they have all preseason? Can Matt Moore flip the switch in the regular season yet again? If those two happen, it hardly matters who we have at receiver, Moore will have time to find them because the line and play-action will give it to him. On defense, I loved what we saw this preseason, but now it’s the regular season, where everything counts. Can we keep it up?
Ready for 2010 football already!!!
Fewell is a fine choice for the Giants as DC...
But, installing a new system requires 1) Having the right players to execute it, and
2) Time for the players to “get it”. The Panthers experienced these growing pains last year before finally becoming the best defense in the league at the end of the year. For this reason, I think the Giants’ defense will struggle for a few weeks at least. On the flip side, we’ve had Meeks’ system in place for a full year, and the players fit the scheme and “get it.”
Last year’s game has little relevance other than the revenge factor, as both teams were missing some key players. The key for the Panthers is to be ready for the emotional factor, and possibly use it to our advantage with screens and draws on offense. Special teams need to be solid, not necessarily spectacular. If we come out flat, we lose. If we come out ready to hit, we win easily. Just my opinion.
Where there’s a will… I want to be in it.
I think it's funny....
The Giants want to improve their defense, so who do they go get?? Somebody from the Bills! Hahaha….that’s like us going and getting a D-Coordinator from Cleveland or Detroit, the worst D in the league…
In fairness
the bills have had one of the best passing defenses in recent years, despite having a lack of big amounts of talent there and a shitty offense.
Against all odds, against all circumstance were you don't have a shot, you succeed
All you hear about is the past, the past... the past is the !@#$ing past, this is the present.
THIS IS TEMPORARY! A CHAMPIONSHIP IS PERMANENT
-Michael Strahan
Maybe.
The rest of their defense was pretty bad though. Did they really have a great pass defense, or did teams just run on them all year? They had the 30th ranked rush defense. It was probably a little of both.
stuff 'bout stuff.
by silver82blade on Sep 12, 2010 11:36 AM EDT up reply actions
You could say the same thing about us.
Ready for 2010 football already!!!
by Flowing Willow on Sep 12, 2010 10:02 PM EDT up reply actions
Domenix Hixon
is out for the season.
Otherwise, good write up.
As a Giants Fan good luck…
… after this week.
Against all odds, against all circumstance were you don't have a shot, you succeed
All you hear about is the past, the past... the past is the !@#$ing past, this is the present.
THIS IS TEMPORARY! A CHAMPIONSHIP IS PERMANENT
-Michael Strahan
Will the real Steve Smith please stand up....

"I’m the UFC Heavyweight Champion and I will be until the day I decide I don’t want to be. And that isn’t anytime soon." - Brock Lesnar
90% picking the Panthers today
I’m glad that that Panthers fan in general are feeling pretty positive about today’s game.
I feel that Giants are going to pull this one off though. Giants have a balanced offense that I think is a little underrated – they can run the ball with Bradshaw and Jacobs and they also have plenty of receiving options. They are likely to attack us with misdirection plays to use the speed of our defense against us. Bear in mind that will have some inexperienced guys on D.
I think our offense will be fine – but we have also installed some new wrinkles in the offensive side of the game. I don’t know that we hit the ground running with all changes. We are playing on the road and I expect a lot of noise – how does our offense respond? Our ability to be competitive in this game maybe dependent on a strong start that would take the fans out of the game.
I would worry that this has the makings of a blowout but Giants also have the added of distraction of being involved in the “Battle for New York” with the Jets. I think the game will be tight.
Giants 22 – Panthers 19
I think the TE's and DL were alright.
They didn’t fail as bad as the other aspects. Rosario made a few nice catches, and I noticed him split out wide a few times. But whether it was a poor throw or a drop, we just couldn’t connect to the TE’s. The DL held pretty well for the first half, but they just wore down. If we can’t get a lead or if we fall behind, that’s going to happen. I also didn’t notice much consistent pressure on Eli Manning. So, yeah, fail.
Ready for 2010 football already!!!
by Flowing Willow on Sep 12, 2010 10:04 PM EDT up reply actions

by 






















