What are the big boards saying?

Despite the lack of games, this is a fun time of the year to be a football fan.  The offseason is full of possibilities; every trade made is for the betterment of the team, all Free Agents will work out, and there's no chance of drafting a bust.  Right now the Front Offices around the league can do no wrong.

Of course, we know that's not how it will work out once the games are played, but being fans we're sure that the mistakes will all happen to other guys.  As a Panthers fan, the cuts were all necessary, we won't miss Peppers (and he won't help the Bears in the NFC North), and every pencilled-in starter in 2010 will make you wonder why we didn't boot all those other players earlier.

And, of course, the draft is looming.  What fun!

This is where we all get to find out who our future stars are.  There are no Eric Sheltons yet, every player we're considering is either a day one starter or a potential stud on Special Teams.  Remember Captain Munnerlyn?  That's the benchmark for us.

So of course, draft sites abound on the net.  Each one promises that their brand of analysis is superior, they alone know what teams really want and need, and that their player rankings reign supreme across the web.

And of course, all of them offer mock drafts that seem so authoritative you wonder why the league even bothers with the real event.  And then the real event finally comes around and makes fools of all the prognosticators.  It happens every year.

Because face it, no one really knows what the GMs around the league will do.  Its easier to understand what women really want than it is to predict Al Davis' next move.  No one knows what trades will happen.  And when you combine an unexpected move with shifting needs, well it's understandable if people consider a 30% prediction rate a success for the first round.

But predict they do!  And not only do they predict, the analyze and research and invest hours in playing the armchair GM.  Which, as appealing as it sounds, is beyond my skill.  

I like to think that I'm good at research, but I'll be the first to admit that I don't have the time to watch a hundred players on YouTube over and over again to try and figure out who's more likely to contribute on Sundays.  That doesn't mean I'm not willing to take advantage of other people's work though.  And that's what this series is all about.

Today's entry is on the "Big Boards" out there.  Every other Draft Site purports to know which players are NFL-ready, and which are more ready than others.  

To do the analysis, I started with Google.  I did a search, and chose the most reputable looking sites I could find that offered top 100 player lists.  Being cheap, I also didn't bother with any of the pay sites.  Based on the reviews I've read, all these pay sites get you is another place to look at the same information that's already out there, tied up in the opinion of someone who isn't any better than the rest at predicting who's going to do what.

So for this exercise, I used nine sources.  I took the top boards of http://www.fantasyfootballjungle.com, http://www.cbssports.com, http://www.cdsdraft.com/, http://www.nfldraftdog.com, http://www.drafttek.com, http://www.nationalfootballpost.com, http://www.walterfootball.com, http://www.fftoolbox.com, and http://www.sidelinescouting.com.

If you're like me, there's a lot of negative things you can say about each site.  But there are a lot of positives as well, and none of them seem to be run by some kid in is parent's basement, acting like an expert on a sport he's never played.

Armed with those sources, I compiled the results in a spreadsheet and then ran a simple average.  But while that got me part of the way towards a nice, consolidated big board, it wasn't enough.

It seems that each board had it's own few pet players; every one out there had a guy who was good enough to be ranked in the top 50 on their own board, but who at the same time managed to escape the notice of everyone else.  For my simple "Everybody's Top 100" list, I had 182 players  to choose from.

How do you average them?  In the end, I simply decided that these players were all almost good enough to be listed on the other boards, and were in fact tied for the 101st best player on all of them.  So, if not too many people shared the National Football Post's opinion that Ciron Black was the 56th best player available, and didn't even list him, I just gave him scores of 101 on all their boards.  In that way, instead of him enjoying an average score of 79.6 on the three boards that listed him, he had a weighted average of 106, which better reflects what everyone thought of his skills.

Some interesting information emerged after consolidating.  For instance, the variations in rating certain positions reveals how much more difficult it is to decide who's more NFL ready among different positions.

For Tight Ends in the top 50, there was a spread of 55.33 between the average high draft position and the average low one.  In other words, everyone agreed on who should be included, just not on where.  For a DT, maybe because of the two at the top, the range was a much lower 17.33.

When you get to the top 100, where a lot of people made one list but not another, the spread becomes even more pronounced. Linebackers and Tackles seem like the safest picks in terms of gaining consensus, and Tight Ends become even more uncertain.

That shows how much easier people think it is to predict success for some positions.  Here's a quick table showing the averages among the consensus top 100 by weighted versus actual and high versus low, then the same information for the top 50.


Top 100 Top 50

Average vs. Weighted
High vs. Low Average vs. Weighted
High vs. Low
CB 8.74 49.75 1.25 37.40
DE 4.12 44.09 0.82 38.43
DT 5.42 31.00 0.00 17.33
ILB 3.05 51.25 0.00 33.00
OG 6.97 59.50 0.00 39.00
OLB 3.39 42.43 0.00 40.67
OT 3.08 40.88 0.00 39.33
QB 4.22 49.60 0.00 38.00
RB 5.17 47.38 0.00 47.25
S 5.66 52.25 0.00 38.75
TE 10.26 55.88 0.00 55.33
WR 4.33 51.90 2.09 51.50

That's kind of interesting in a geeky sort of way.  It gets better when you look at the various mock drafts out there.  A lot of prognosticators want to sell you on how good a player is on their big board while taking them with a relatively late selection themselves in their mock. 

For instance, a guy like Trent Williams is barely cracking the top 20 on the big boards out there, but several mocks have him as a top ten pick.  And everyone knows Sam Bradford is the number one pick, but he's still considered the fifth best player out there. 

But that analysis is for a future article.

Without further discussion, here's the combined Big Board from the aforementioned sites.  Enjoy, and don't forget.  We're just the messenger here. :)

 

Name Position Average Rating Weighted Average Rating Highest Rating Lowest Rating
1 Ndamukong Suh DT 1.22 1.22 1 2
2 Eric Berry S 2.78 2.78 1 5
3 Gerald McCoy DT 2.89 2.89 2 4
4 Russell Okung OT 4.56 4.56 4 7
5 Sam Bradford QB 9.22 9.22 1 31
6 Rolando McClain ILB 9.67 9.67 5 17
7 Derrick Morgan DE 10.67 10.67 6 25
8 Joe Haden CB 11.22 11.22 7 22
9 Dez Bryant WR 11.56 11.56 6 19
10 C. J. Spiller RB 11.89 11.89 5 22
11 Bryan Bulaga OT 12.89 12.89 6 23
12 Jimmy Clausen QB 15.22 15.22 5 51
13 Jason Pierre-Paul DE 17.11 17.11 8 44
14 Mike Iupati OG 19.00 19.00 8 29
15 Brandon Graham DE 20.22 20.22 11 37
16 Dan Williams DT 20.56 20.56 16 29
17 Earl Thomas S 23.44 23.44 10 53
18 Trent Williams OT 23.44 23.44 8 75
19 Bruce Campbell OT 23.89 23.89 9 63
20 Anthony Davis OT 24.44 24.44 8 65
21 Kyle Wilson CB 25.33 25.33 18 32
22 Jerry Hughes DE 26.00 26.00 12 38
23 Taylor Mays S 27.56 27.56 13 60
24 Sergio Kindle OLB 28.00 28.00 15 71
25 Brian Price DT 28.67 28.67 14 53
26 Sean Weatherspoon OLB 28.67 28.67 20 49
27 Jared Odrick DT 29.00 29.00 17 36
28 Maurkice Pouncey OG 30.67 30.67 4 61
29 Everson Griffen DE 31.44 31.44 10 70
30 Jermaine Gresham TE 31.44 31.44 10 49
31 Jahvid Best RB 31.56 31.56 9 57
32 Golden Tate WR 32.78 32.78 12 72
33 Arrelious Benn WR 33.22 33.22 14 55
34 Terrence Cody DT 33.33 33.33 19 49
35 Devin McCourty CB 33.89 33.89 23 62
36 Carlos Dunlap DE 36.89 36.89 22 63
37 Charles Brown OT 36.89 36.89 22 60
38 Ryan Mathews RB 40.56 40.56 22 85
39 Daryl Washington ILB 43.78 43.78 30 84
40 Ricky Sapp OLB 48.56 48.56 31 68
41 Demaryius Thomas WR 43.00 49.44 34 101
42 Rob Gronkowski TE 50.56 50.56 35 78
43 Patrick Robinson CB 44.88 51.11 37 101
44 Kareem Jackson CB 52.11 52.11 33 88
45 Damian Williams WR 46.38 52.44 12 101
46 Jonathan Dwyer RB 52.67 52.67 21 82
47 Aaron Hernandez TE 54.00 54.00 6 90
48 Nate Allen S 54.00 54.00 27 88
49 Corey Wootton DE 49.25 55.00 40 101
50 Brandon LaFell WR 55.67 55.67 34 73
51 Eric Norwood OLB 58.22 58.22 33 73
52 Colt McCoy QB 46.57 58.67 35 101
53 Rodger Saffold OG 54.13 59.33 37 101
54 Chad Jones S 54.88 60.00 38 101
55 Dominique Franks CB 56.63 61.56 45 101
56 Navorro Bowman OLB 56.75 61.67 40 101
57 Brandon Spikes ILB 59.63 64.22 18 101
58 Morgan Burnett S 55.00 65.22 23 101
59 Chris Cook CB 62.25 66.56 39 101
60 Vladimir Ducasse OT 50.17 67.11 43 101
61 Tim Tebow QB 64.75 68.78 43 101
62 Jon Asamoah OG 69.22 69.22 44 91
63 Brandon Ghee CB 61.00 69.89 32 101
64 Dexter McCluster WR 66.75 70.56 52 101
65 Toby Gerhart RB 64.43 72.56 38 101
66 Arthur Jones DT 58.50 72.67 38 101
67 John Jerry OG 65.14 73.11 14 101
68 Sean Lee ILB 66.86 74.44 45 101
69 Tyson Alualu DT 67.43 74.89 45 101
70 Jason Worilds DE 76.22 76.22 33 91
71 Mardy Gilyard WR 69.29 76.33 40 101
72 Matt Tennant OG 66.00 77.67 20 101
73 Jacoby Ford WR 71.71 78.22 56 101
74 Koa Misi OLB 66.83 78.22 58 101
75 Ed Dickson TE 62.20 79.44 40 101
76 Perrish Cox CB 68.67 79.44 52 101
77 Cam Thomas DT 62.80 79.78 52 101
78 Greg Hardy DE 71.83 81.56 39 101
79 Lamarr Houston DT 68.00 82.67 56 101
80 Montario Hardesty RB 74.00 83.00 50 101
81 J.D. Walton OG 61.25 83.33 25 101
82 Jermaine Cunningham DE 61.75 83.56 47 101
83 Tony Pike QB 78.71 83.67 53 101
84 Eric Decker WR 70.80 84.22 46 101
85 Anthony McCoy TE 63.75 84.44 43 101
86 Reshad Jones S 76.50 84.67 43 101
87 Alex Carrington DE 77.00 85.00 59 101
88 Jared Veldheer OT 77.83 85.56 68 101
89 Thaddeus Gibson OLB 78.67 86.11 70 101
90 Ben Tate RB 79.17 86.44 71 101
91 Dorin Dickerson TE 74.80 86.44 51 101
92 Anthony Dixon RB 70.50 87.44 55 101
93 Jimmy Graham TE 76.80 87.56 48 101
94 Trevard Lindley CB 42.50 88.00 29 101
95 Donovan Warren CB 78.20 88.33 62 101
96 Geno Atkins DT 82.00 88.33 77 101
97 Jerome Murphy CB 75.50 89.67 38 101
98 Mike Johnson OG 81.20 90.00 58 101
99 Kam Chancellor S 68.33 90.11 37 101
100 Tony Moeaki TE 68.33 90.11 42 101
X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

Join Cat Scratch Reader

You must be a member of Cat Scratch Reader to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Cat Scratch Reader. You should read them.

Join Cat Scratch Reader

You must be a member of Cat Scratch Reader to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Cat Scratch Reader. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9341_tracker