Saints LB Marvin Mitchell was fined $10,000 for a major facemask on Panthers RB Mike Goodson last week.
From Gantt via Twitter
over 1 year ago
Scrantsj
16 comments
0 recs |
Comments
NO MAN HURTS MUNNERLYN AND GETS AWAY WITH IT
by Ol' Uncle Munnerlyn on Oct 8, 2010 8:00 PM EDT reply actions
lmfao
Got this play and the one where Cap’n got rocked confused :S
by Ol' Uncle Munnerlyn on Oct 8, 2010 8:30 PM EDT up reply actions
Not nearly enough, but at least there was finally some action taken.
I literally wrote the NFL – I was furious that there wasn’t a fine/suspension placed on Mitchel by the next day. I recorded the game on my DVR, and I watched that facemask multiple times. No one could have missed that unless he had his back turned to the field. OFFICIALS – I’m talking to you. It doesn’t take 10 seconds to think that that maybe warranted a flag. And no one with an ounce of sincerity could have said it was “incidental.” It was a disgustingly cheap and dirty shot – plain and simple. If I were Sean Payton, Mitchell’s ass wouldn’t get a jersey and step foot on that field for several weeks. I get that football is a physical game, and that you should play with physicality and passion to help your team win. But play with some freaking dignity instead of trying to break Goodson’s neck. It is literally incredibly that Goodson was able to walk away from that. If the roles were reversed and a Panther did that to a Saints player, I’d be just as angry (I’ve only been watching the Panthers since shortly before Moore took over for Delhomme last season, but I can’t remeber a Panther taking that kind of shot during that time period). I want my team to win with pure talent and without resorting to that kind of crap.
Which reminds me of the commentators’ remarks about Brandon LaFell’s hit on special teams coverage earlier in the game. I can’t remember what player LaFell was blocking, but that Saints player was about to run into Goodson’s running lane. LaFell did his job, and he did it well. He lowered his shoulder into the Saints player’s shoulder. There was nothing remotely resembling near head contact. Yet the commentators had to say that players should avoid hits like that “out of respect for other players.” WTF? LaFell legitimately performed exactly as he was supposed to. Yet Mitchell’s grabbing of Goodson’s facemask and ripping his head down to the side was “incidental”?
Commentators and officials – try working on making your biases a little less obvious. Yeah, the Saints won the Super Bowl last year and are playing relatively well. But that doesn’t give them a free pass to play dirty. If they could play without shots like Mitchell took, I’d have some respect for that talent. But now I am disgusted by that team.
I don’t mean to anger any Saints fan’s who may happen to read this blog, but I’m calling it the way I honestly see it.
by jamiedk on Oct 9, 2010 11:23 AM EDT reply actions 3 recs
Solid commentary jamiedk (rec'd). When I watched the game again, I noticed this incident
just happened to occur on the next kickoff after the one Goodson brought back to mid-field. And you’re on the money about Lafell’s block as well. When Moose Johnson started talking about it being cheap, it was like WTF are talking about. He’s an ex-fullback complaining about a completely legal and appropriate de-cleater. Unbelievable.
Where there’s a will… I want to be in it.
Thanks Rick!
I mean, come on. I’m a girl and I’ve only been watching football since 2008 when I went to Texas Tech and watched the incredible duo of Graham Harrell and Michael Crabtree, and where Tech’s O-line dominated. ESPN or ABC showed an aerial shot of their O-line, and they made a perfect pocket around Harrell at least 90% of the time and gave him all of the time in the world to let his receivers get open. By the way, I was on the fifth row at the corner of the field where Crabtree made that last second, game-winning catch against Texas – that sealed my fascination with football.
Anyway, point being – if a girl who has only watched football for 2 years can call out the kind of crap that happened in last week’s game, those officials and commentators should look for a new job. I don’t pretend to know everything about football – I obviously don’t; never played and never watched until two years ago. But I swear I could give better commentary that half of the ones who do it week-in-and-out. And don’t even get me started on Fox/Davidson. I don’t know what discussions go on in meetings and in the locker room, and I don’t know who the buck stops with as far as offensive play calling goes, but I swear that if I just studied the NFL rulebook, then even I could run the offense better than Fox/Davidson. All of the offense’s problems start with the calls on the plays and with the right side of the O-line (even though I have to give credit to Shwartz – he stepped up his game against the Saints). If Fox and/or Davidson would bring their game up to par, the improvement would trickle down to the effectiveness of every other position on offense. Then we would have the potential to be a threat in the league seeing as how the defense has largely been very effective. I mean, Anderson’s stats last week were insane.
By the way...
Sorry for the few typos in my previous posts. I was an English major in undergrad…so it kills me to go back and see typos. I’m a little OCD. Haha.
You go, girl!
Keep posting. You’re a keen observer.
Where have you been all my life?
Why aren’t there more like you? lol. You are awesome!!!!
I am an optimist. It does not seem too much use being anything else.
~Winston Churchill
OH!
Rec'd btw
I am an optimist. It does not seem too much use being anything else.
~Winston Churchill
OH!
Haha...
I have found that talking football while taking a shot or two of Jack in a bar does work in my favor.
Let's recap...you're a girl who loves football (esp the Panthers) and drinking shots in a bar....
I predict you’ll make LOTSA friends on this site, jamie!
Make sure you ask for their IDs, though.
sweety sweety
Take it easy. You are getting me all riled up now. You say one more cool thing and I’m off to Jared’s…
I am an optimist. It does not seem too much use being anything else.
~Winston Churchill
OH!
by STEVEN 785 on Oct 9, 2010 8:01 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
LaFell's block was on Pierson Prioleau, their safety, and it took him out of the game.
Good observation that it was a clean, aggressive, totally proper block, and textbook how a STer should play his position.
I rec’d your excellent post.





















