Cat Scratch Reader: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Anonymous Eagle covering Marquette!

Are the NFL too harsh with fines and penalties?

There is something weird going on in the NFL this year, and it has quietly happened all year with hardly anyone really talking about it. Why are there so many fines going out this year as opposed to years in the past? For the fans in Charlotte we already have 2 perfect contrasting examples of a good call and a bad call against the Panthers, and I'm sure that by now we've all heard of what happened with the Chargers game in week one. Let me just go over the two we know about though, which was Lance Briggs hit on Jake Delhomme in week 2 while he was on the ground, and Julius Peppers hit on Matt Ryan in week 4 as he was throwing the ball.

First off, it was clearly obvious that Jake Delhomme was on the ground when he was hit by Lance Briggs in week 2. Jake Delhomme slid feet first to get another yard or so and instead of tapping Delhomme down, Lance Briggs decided it would be better to take off his head while he was on the ground. If you want to tackle Delhomme like that you need to sack him in the pocket. Don't try to slam him while he's on the ground because you can't break the O-Line and you want a cheap hit. In any event, Lance Briggs received no penalty for the play, and the NFL released a statement later that Lance Briggs would not be fined because "He was already committed to the diving tackle." http://blogs.chicagosports.chicagotribune.com/huddleup/2008/09/no-fine-for-lan.html

Under that logic, you get the idea that any tackle is alright to do as long as you commit to the tackle and you follow through it right? Yet just a couple of weeks later, Julius Peppers gets penalized for unnecessary roughness and a fine later called on him for tackling Matt Ryan as soon as he threw the football, negating a interception return for a TD that drew lots of attention to that particular play and made the whole stadium furious. This completely opposes the following philosophy established in the previous game and leaves Panther players scratching their heads. How can you go for a tackle on a Quarterback if you always face the risk of him throwing the ball and getting called for a penalty? The NFL later defined this penalty as Julius Peppers "Leading with his shoulder but then hit Matt Ryan in the head." http://news.yahoo.com/s/cpress/20081003/ca_pr_on_fo/nfl_peppers_fined_2

At some point you have to step back and realize that this is a manly sport. This isn't a game for little girls. People are going to get hit and bones will be broken. This is such a violent sport that you can't play this game professionally unless you really enjoy doing it. You play it because you love to hit people, love to put people on the ground, run into the endzone after making a big catch and all of that good stuff. Yet as you look around the league, you see goofy contrasting calls like the two I just showed you and fines being sent out for simple silly things like dancing in the endzone. The fines on endzone dances are especially stupid, because you're starting to fine someone for celebrating what he does for a living. As long as he isn't spurting out gang signs or shooting the moon, why do they really care?

Unless of course they're passing out fines just to get money.

That's where it gets interesting. One of the biggest points of penalties and fines in the NFL is to protect the players from getting hurt after the play is over. But when they start chalking up fines for dancing and hitting a QB, you start to wonder the motive behind these fines. After all, exactly how much does it hurt the game of football when Ronnie Brown does his thing in the endzone? If I see some bad refs let go at the end of the season or even punished then I'll know that it's just me. But if that doesn't happen, I call shenanigans on the NFL.

 

0 recs  |  Comment 3 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

One thing to remember

While I can’t say I disagree, I do believe the fines are given to charity and not back to the league.

by LittleKing on Oct 18, 2008 9:35 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

You are right on Revshawn

Troy P with pittsburgh agrees with you. Did you see his comments over the weekend?

I blog the Carolina Panthers at www.catscratchreader.com

by Jaxon on Oct 20, 2008 8:27 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

As far as the fines...

there’s speculation there are sending the money to a NFL Retired Players “Charity”, I imagine where the dudes that played in the NFL for just a short period of time and spent all their jack now get hand-outs.

I blog the Carolina Panthers at www.catscratchreader.com

by Jaxon on Oct 20, 2008 8:29 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog focused on the NFL's Carolina Panthers.

Site Code of Conduct

Start posting about the Panthers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Deangello_pimp_small
Here's why the Panthers should trade for our #2 WR
Chris_harris_headshot_2_small
My Thoughts on Jake Delhomme Being Cut from the Panthers - @ChrisHarrisNFL
Terminatorstewart_small
An Ode to Jake Delhomme... "He is our Quarterback"
Terminatorstewart_small
Panther Fans Weigh in on Vick's Panther Preference

Recent FanPosts

Travisandcayce_yahoo
Upcoming Season
Chris_harris_headshot_2_small
'Hitting Hard with Chris Harris' - CarolinaHuddle.com
Small
Shaun Hill granted wish for trade and should Panthers pounce ? Heck Yeah.
Small
Did I just say T.O?
Chiefs_small
Thoughts from Panthers Fans?
Funny-hilarious-kid-child-pics-162_small
Scouts.com Top 100 Prospects for the 2010 Draft
131_small
Charles Grant
102_1463_small
Who's really making all the moves?
Currentflag_small
Stefan Logan anyone? 'Yes please!' says the Aussie

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Buffalo Rumblings
DT Kennedy re-ups with Vikings
Silver And Black Pride
How Much Influence Does Tom Cable Have?
Arrowhead Pride
Former Chiefs Assistant Coach Joins Clancy Pendergast At Cal

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Referee Michael Batlan, left, grabs USC defensive end Everson Griffen before throwing a flag for unsportsmanlike conduct in the third quarter during an NCAA college football game against Notre Dame in South Bend, Ind., Saturday, Oct. 17, 2009. USC defeated Notre Dame 34-27. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)

NFL Draft 2010 Player Profile: Everson Griffen, USC Defensive End

Photo

NFL Draft 2010 Player Profile: Darryl Washington, TCU Linebacker

Florida tight end Aaron Hernandez (81) catches a pass from quarterback Tim Tebow and is tackled Arkansas linebacker Wendel Davis during the first half of an NCAA college football game in Gainesville, Fla., Saturday, Oct. 17, 2009.(AP Photo/Phil Sandlin)

NFL Draft 2010 Player Profile: Aaron Hernandez, Florida Tight End

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Catscratchreader_m_small Jaxon

Editors

N1523447507_30151367_6579_small Cyberjag

Img_0764_small LittleKing

Currentflag_small James The Aussie

Authors

Dbc92c5112a9b23c_small Revshawn