Patriots vs. Panthers: Handing Out the Grades
If the goal of preseason is to prepare for the regular season then the Panthers still need a few more games, preferably against lesser opponents. Unfortunately they only have one more tune-up game to start getting it right. Make no mistake; the Patriots outclassed the Panthers on their way to a 24-7 preseason victory Friday night. The Patriot offense moved the ball fairly easily and consistently. The Patriot defense stuffed the Panthers retooled running game. On special teams, the Patriots bull rushed the kicking game on their way to blocking two field goals. There were a few bright spots for the Panthers last night which I will highlight below. Overall the best that can be said for the last two preseason games is that the Panthers are in no danger of becoming overconfident. This game did not provide the boost of confidence the home crowd was hoping to see.
The Offense
The Panthers improved running game ground to a halt against the Patriots vaunted D-line (57 yds total). On the flip side the Panthers improved the passing game and also had better success on third down. After a third-down drop by Carter on his first pass both he and Colbert later redeemed themselves with clutch catches. Colbert provided the lone big play of the night for the Panthers on a 48 yard catch from the slot where he made a nice move to avoid the safety for the score. I give kudos to Steve Smith for a nice downfield block on the CB to spring Colbert. Jake had a pretty good night statistically (11-18, 162, 1 TD) but in the end couldn’t sustain any drives for TD’s. The line did a better job protecting the QB but the receivers overall dropped to many passes. The second team didn’t fare any better as Dwayne Jarrett (2 for 24 yds) had his biggest night to date with the Panthers. David Carr led a nice drive late in the third only to throw an interception in the red zone. Overall it was an improvement from the previous week but is still a work in process.Grade: C-
The Defense
The Panthers defense did provide some stops and occasional nice plays against the Patriots early. Yet Brady again showed why he a master of the short passing game and dinked and doinked the Panthers for two scores and a field goal. The run defense played better with Morgan in the line up yet Lawrence Maroney still put up 58 yards on 15 carries. The pass defense prevented the big play for the most part but couldn’t cover the crossing routes or the short dumps and couldn’t put any pressure on Brady. Jon Beason saw extended action and made some big hits and flashed great speed. On a downside he failed to wrap up the runner a couple times and allowed the runner extra yardage. It’s obvious the Panthers are playing a vanilla zone defense and are not blitzing very much; choosing to keep their cards close to the vest in the preseason. Overall the Patriot offense kept the defense off-balance for most of the night. Grade C+
Special Teams
The Panthers covered kicks fairly well and Jason Baker continued his good work punting. Nick Goings took a step back on the kick off returns with several less than adequate returns. He either wasn’t following his blocking or wasn’t getting any at all. Any positive progress on special teams was undone by the field goal unit. The Panthers not once but twice allowed penetration directly up the middle of the line for the block. I have to think this was not the usual blockers up front. If not this has to be a major concern for the coaching staff going forward. Grade: D-
Overall this score card represents another ugly loss for the Panthers. They have one more game to get it right and hopefully provide themselves and their fans a much needed boost of confidence prior to the season opening kick off.
0 recs |
5 comments
Comments
the game
I'm not concerned at all. The Panthers staff doesn't game plan during the preseason. We work on executing our plays correctly, and if we had done so, we would've been more competitive. For example, you don't beed to gameplan against a superior defense to know you should catch the ball on third down or make sure you wrap the guy when you make a tackle.
Keary Colbert looked good. I think we need to have more three receiver, single RB sets where we rotate through Colbert, Carter and Garrett. Zone blocking is definiely better for our running game and since it's new to our guys, they'll get better at it as the season progresses. Also, zone blocking works better when you game plan for it by planning against specific players like Adalius Thomas, something we didn't do, but we will do in the reg season.
When the final cuts are made, there should be some decent safeties available. We should get one. Even if our starters were All-Pro, which they obviously aren't, we don't have enough - Harris, Salley and Cooper. If we have anymore than that, they don't count cuz the talent level of those three isn't exactly intimidating.
D-Lines also have to game plan against the other teams blocking schemes. Our staff didn't do that. They do in the regular season. That's why we didn't get much pressure on Brady.
So the bottom line is that we need to work on some fundamental things like route running, catching, tackling (it sounds worse than it really is), and we'll be good to go. Even after watching the last two games, I'm confident we'll get to the Super Bowl, especially if Andy Reid's alcoholic kids get into more trouble, and McNabb is on a four game losing streak.
by usana_gaines on Aug 25, 2007 11:52 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
It's true
by Jaxon on Aug 26, 2007 10:13 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
i agree
by usana_gaines on Aug 26, 2007 10:49 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Preaseason means nothing
Yes we looked really bad the last two weeks but this is preseason, we went 4-0 last year and where did it get us? 8-8.
It is better to see the chinks in the armor now than to have to discover problems later on when it counts. Besides I still think Fox isnt showing his full hand to the league right now so they cannot plan for us as well.
The only thing that concerns me is special teams, that was their starting lineup and it looks no better than last year with the exception of the upgrade with Robinson returning punts
by manu4t on Aug 26, 2007 1:27 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Correct
We are running few blitzes or stunts and playing vanilla defenses. The offensive play calling has been limited as well. We are in no danger of becoming over confident which I think will be good too. Playing against these good teams in preseason will help once we go up against lesser teams at the start of the season.
by Jaxon on Aug 27, 2007 8:11 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 














